pdf download

Scientific Method ?  -MOVIE

Given the immense scientific focus over the last two decades and more of the landing of robotic rovers on Mars.... -sixteen years ago this month, and the resulting exploration of the planet -as well as the more recent excitement of finding "organic compounds" on the surface (2012)... it might be appropriate to begin a discussion with regard to this very important enterprise on the surface of this desolate, forsaken planet, currently about 47 million miles away.

   ...and to ask why did we go there?

............what is Life?

In the early 1960's, James Lovelock was invited by NASA to participate in the scientific research for evidence of life on Mars. His job was to design instruments, capable of detecting the presence of life, which could be sent on a spacecraft to Mars. This wasn't straightforward, since it was hard to know what to test for: any life forms on Mars may be radically different from those on Earth.

This led him to think about what constitutes life, and how it can be detected. He decided that the most general characteristic of life was that it takes in energy and matter and discards waste products. He also reasoned that organisms would use the planet's atmosphere as a medium for this cyclic exchange, just as we breathe in oxygen and expel carbon dioxide.

David Orrell

......................When you consider the tasks of the twin rovers "Spirit" and "Opportunity" and the more recent "Perseverence"  , the question, as to "what is 'Life'?", is not such a straight forward question, after all?

Some Classical definitions of Life...... -online Merriam-Webster Dictionary, life defines "life" as “an organismic state characterized by capacity for metabolism, growth, reaction to stimuli, and reproduction.”

If we can't even agree on how to address the question as it stands (or at least "pidgeonhole" or catagorize LIFE), can we at least identify some characteristics or concepts that we hope might encompass all or some of the "known" living, Life forms?

.... and then study them.

Some texts try to categorize these "life forms" as having various potentials........ "to reproduce", "to grow" and "to evolve". 

.....crystals can reproduce, mountains and landscapes can grow, the earth has "evolved".

So what, or how, would we define a Life form?

But, why limit ourselves to only one simple definition? 

Why not make a composite of some -if not a number- of these definitions?

1) Living things need to take in energy
2) Living things get rid of "waste"
3) Living things grow and develop
4) Living things respond to their environment
5) Living things reproduce and pass their traits onto their offspring
6) Over time, living things evolve (change slowly) in response to their environment

Not all living organims have ALL thes attributes, moreover, we end up with the same problem as before...

Why is this question so hard?

Many living things can be made up of a lot of "dead" material.........

Similarly, some seemingly living things may not actually be....."ALIVE"... .

Wendell Stanley, 1946... no metabolism of their own.... More recently, however, viruses fall ill.....and potentially acquire their own immune system. So, are they alive?

Because, for every hard, fast and simple definition of "Life" that we can come up with, we can probably come up with a variety of seemingly analogous systems/objects that one could normally identify as being "inanimate" or (as John Cleese might say..). "bereft of life", and we end up arguing -along with Supreme Court Associate Justice, Justice Stewart Potter in trying to wrestle with the "definition" of obscenity, circa 1964 and use the argument "but I know it when I see it".

What we DO know is that LIFE is what makes Biology so interesting... and so broad in scope such that it simultaneously differentiates itself from the rest of the Natural Sciences, while at the same time incorporates many aspects of inherent features of these "other" natural sciences.

As such, whatever these "life forms" are, our experience has taught us that -in order to exist- they must stay within the bounds of scientific laws that have been established for the physical and chemical world.....?

Which begs the next question........What is a "Scientific Law"? 

A Scientific Law is: "a descriptive generalization about how some aspect of the natural world behaves under stated circumstances".

Let's take another tack.....Where, can Life NOT exist……?

Within a state of "chaos" or entropy, or in a vacuum

Potentially, therefore, a prerequisite for Life is........, an "organization" that is able to harness the laws of the physical world, allowing "life" (whatever it is) to perpetuate, and -at the very least- reproduce itself.

OK, so "what are the minimal requirements for life to exist?".

hint:

"Good fences make good neighbours"

 

 Robert Frost in "Mending Wall"

 

While this was written as a tongue in cheek commentary on our apparently inherent conditioning to rebuild our fences, defining ourselves by the "fences" that we build and rebuild, maybe it goes deeper than that, may be....

"The molecules and cells that form our tissues are continually removed and replaced;

it is the maintenance of pattern and architecture, I reasoned, that we call life."

Donald Ingber SCI American, Jan. 1998.

 

Indeed, among all the potential variables on living organisms, one critical factor, that is paramount to ALL living organisms is that they are all boundered by a well defined, specific and reproducible boundary, or fence.  Minimally, therefore, we can say that "Life is organized".

As a result of what we have discussed thus far I would venture to suggest some additional, important aspects/requirements of living organisms:

(a) Living organisms exist, subject to the laws of chemistry and physics,

(b) the very act of living requires energy. 

(c) to survive -at least in our world- living organisms use organic atoms..."C H O N P S" to effectively cycle and recycle the available energy (in all its forms).... at the energetic expense of the local environment. Life is the ultimate capitalist.

 

We will come back to each of these aspects again and again throughout the course, but for now, because you might not have thought about them for a while, let me re-aquaint you with the basic "building blocks" of Life, and how these building blocks potentially interact and "reproduce" themselves in living systems.

The Biochemistry of Living forms.

Organic matter: Carbon, Hydrogen, Oxygen,…(C H O N P S)...

The Biochemist's perspective on "Life" can be appreciated as being a series of "cycles", Carbon, Nitrogen, Sulphur with a few requisite metals thrown in for good measure...

   

So, long with these quite different and limited need for the periodic table of elements, we can see that Life (whatever it "is" has a major influence on its own chemistry...

Oh by the way, life is also "British" !!!

...the importance of driving on the "right" side of the road, or more correctly, the importance of a good "hand shake"!!!!

         

Just like humans, molecules have a potential "mirror image" or chirality. While most non-living molecules are racemic mixtures of either form, living organims have developed a homochirality "rule" to allow for the formation of more complex, intricate structures that are Stereo specific.... L-amino acids and D-Sugars

The organinc chemist William Bonner spent 25 (he claimed "wasted") years trying to find a non-biological origin for these dominance of these biologically relevant forms.

Proteins:polymers of amino acids that are assembled into a chain in a manner that is determined by the blue print. And once assembled provides a function. Once the function is achieved, the protein is then recycled into its constituent parts, only to be "re-constructed" under the direction of the message written in the mRNA.

  

Nucleic acids: merely different storage materials of reproducible ribbons of "order" that provide the "blue print" for the maintenance of the living structure.

            

Sugars, Polysaccharides and Fats: paradoxically, though essential for life to exist, these are the transient, and yet stable forms of all living organisms.

         

One of the curiousities about Life, is that it also always requires an inherent, sustainable form of energy to maintain it's existence. 

The currency? One particular nucleotide, ATP!!!